Frontinus Declares Siege Inventions Have Reached Their Limit
Around 85 CE, Frontinus opened his Strategemata by brushing past engines, claiming their “invention… has long since reached its limit,” and turning instead to cunning in siegecraft [8, 35]. His remark assumes a stable toolkit—rams, towers, torsion frames—that any commander recognized. The drama moved from workshop to war room.
What Happened
Sextus Julius Frontinus wore several hats: senator, general, water commissioner, writer. In his Strategemata he collected stratagems—clever ploys that tilted battles and sieges. Right at the start he nods toward machines—rams, towers, engines of war—and then turns away with a line that has echoed through discussions of Roman technology: “Laying aside also all considerations of works and engines of war, the invention of which has long since reached its limit…” [8, 35].
Read literally, it sounds like resignation. Read in context, it is a claim of maturity. By the time Trajan would later finish his column a generation on, the machine kit on those spiraling reliefs was familiar: cart‑mounted carroballistae, siege towers, battering rams slung from tall frames. Vitruvius had already fixed the proportions of skein boxes and taught tuning by ear; Josephus had described machine‑saturated sieges [5, 6, 25]. There was little to add, much to apply.
Frontinus’ focus, then, is on how to use stability. How do you feint a sally under cover of artillery fire? How do you move a tower across broken ground near Antioch? How do you keep morale when stones as white as bone arc against the sky and land with a crack you feel in your sternum? His text offers answers through examples rather than engineering diagrams.
The line also reveals a Roman cultural comfort with certain kinds of progress and a relative indifference to others. Precision in proportion—skein holes at one‑ninth bolt length—and discipline in labor—standard camps with 50–100‑foot streets and a 200‑foot intervallum—mattered. Novel machines less so. The army built capacity into routines: measure, tune, deploy, rotate crews. Surprise came from timing and deception, not from a new gear [1, 5, 37].
Walk from Frontinus’ sentence to the museums of London or the British Museum and you see its shadow. Bolt heads of Manning Type I sit in cases, identical in Dorset and along the Rhine. A technology that “reached its limit” in invention had reached its apex in consistency, like a well‑made hammer used in a thousand hands [26, 31].
Trajan’s Column later broadcasts the same message in marble. Engineers at work, yes; but not unveiling miracles. The quiet pride is in order—roads cut through forest above the Danube, bridgework that stands in flood, artillery trundling on carts behind crimson‑cloaked officers. The empire decided that the best machine is one that always behaves.
Why This Matters
Frontinus’ remark reframes the conversation from invention to application. It declares that the Roman toolkit—rams, towers, torsion artillery—had achieved a reliable standard. The implication is programmatic: invest in training, logistics, and cunning rather than chasing novelty [8]. That is the same logic that made Polybius’ camp plan central to Roman life [1].
The sentence also aligns with the theme of routine power. If engines are stable, then siegecraft becomes about belts, timing, and morale. That’s how Alesia works—obstacles and towers in measured ranks—and how Jotapata falls—160 engines operating like a chorus [4, 6]. It’s how Masada’s wall goes up in weeks, with the same ditch‑and‑agger grammar transposed to desert [10].
For historians, Frontinus helps to date the perceived plateau in Roman military technology. After Vitruvius codified parameters and before Ammianus still heard the rams thud at Amida, the army managed continuity rather than invention [5, 7]. That continuity kept Roman engineering effective for centuries, even as political fortunes shifted.
Event in Context
See what happened before and after this event in the timeline
Ask About This Event
Have questions about Frontinus Declares Siege Inventions Have Reached Their Limit? Get AI-powered insights based on the event details.